Coleman Xtreme Cooler Review: Putting the Competition to Shame

If you’re looking for a good Coleman Xtreme Cooler review, it’s probably because you’re shopping for an affordable alternative to some of the bigger cooler brands out there. It’s no secret that this particular cooler has a significantly smaller price tag than many similar products.

But as we all know, a lower price often means lower quality. So can the Coleman Xtreme really hold it own against the competition?

Before investing in this cooler, there are a few things you need to know. Is this a quality product that will stand the test of time? Will it keep your drinks cold during long trips into the wilderness?

And of course, how does this product compare to other quality coolers? These are some of the things you need to know in a Coleman Xtreme Cooler review.

WHAT IS THE COLEMAN XTREME COOLER?

The Coleman Xtreme Cooler is an impressively large cooler. In fact, this cooler is capable of holding up to 100 canned drinks at a time!

Coleman Cooler | Xtreme Cooler Keeps Ice Up to 5 Days |...
  • XTREME TECHNOLOGY: Insulated...
  • HIGH CAPACITY: Holds up to 100...
  • HAVE-A-SEAT LID: Closed lid...
  • CUP HOLDERS: Molded into the...
  • COMFORT-GRIP HANDLES: No-crush...

This cooler also features an inch of insulation. As a result, it claims to be able to retain ice for up to five days at a time. We’ll put this claim to the virtual test in a moment.

Furthermore, it uses low CO2 insulation, which reduces carbon emissions from foam manufacturing. This will certainly appeal to people who care about protecting the environment. This product is made in the United States.


Where to buy

WHAT ELSE SHOULD YOU KNOW IN A COLEMAN XTREME COOLER REVIEW?

There’s obviously much more to learn in a Coleman Xtreme Cooler review. Here are a few of the things you need to know before you make a purchase.



What are its main features?

The Coleman Xtreme Cooler has a few very convenient extra features. One of these is its sturdy "Have a Seat" lid, which can support up to 250 pounds. This ensures you always have a place to sit during your adventures.

Additionally, this lid has a smooth texture that makes it easy to clean. Just wipe it down real fast, and you’ll be ready for the next trip.

Furthermore, this cooler features No Crush handles that stop before they can pinch your fingers. This makes the cooler exceptionally easy to carry. Finally, the cooler has four convenient cup holders molded into the lid.


How is its ice retention?

Naturally, this is the main thing you want to learn in a Coleman Xtreme Cooler review. As mentioned before, this cooler promises to keep your ice cold for five days at a time. But of course, you can’t always take the manufacturer’s word for it.

That said, this cooler comes shockingly close to hitting this goal. On average, it only misses the five-day mark by a few hours.

As you’ll probably expect, the Coleman Xtreme’s ice retention doesn’t truly compare to more expensive brands. But for the price, it stays cold for a decent amount of time. Odds are, you’ll be able to use it for a weekend trip at the very least.

To see for yourself how long this cooler can last, check out this video.


Is it durable?

Sadly, this is where the Coleman Xtreme starts to show its limitations. Simply put, it’s just not as durable as many of the other coolers on the market.

Unlike more expensive coolers, this cooler doesn’t have a rubber seal around the lid. Because of this, it’s not airtight or leakproof.

The handles are flimsy and likely to break under too much pressure. Also, almost every Coleman Xtreme Cooler review complains about the drain plug’s design. It’s poor quality, and it’s positioned too high to drain water effectively.

On the bright side, the lid really can support up to 250 pounds. But in terms of general durability, the Coleman Xtreme falls far short of the competition.

HOW WE REVIEWED

When reviewing these products, we used professional reviews and the products’ official websites as our primary sources of information. Also, our opinions were largely informed by a combination of product research, professional review, and customer reviews.

For these reviews, we chose to focus on a few key areas. These include ice retention, durability, portability, and main features.


HOW DOES IT COMPARE TO OTHER COOLERS?

Obviously, a good Coleman Xtreme Cooler review should look at the competition as well. There are tons of great coolers on the market today. Let’s see how the Coleman Xtreme Cooler measures up.


IGLOO MARINE ULTRA COOLER

Igloo Marine Ultra Cooler (White, 72-Quart)
  • Ultratherm insulated body and...
  • Stain and odor resistant liner
  • UV Inhibitors to protect...
  • Reinforced comfort grip...
  • Dimensions 30.06in L x 16.5in...

The IGLOO Marine Ultra Cooler is a good choice if you love to fish. This cooler features an ultratherm insulated body and lid. As a result, it claims to be able to retain ice for five days at a time.

One other unique feature is the fish measuring ruler that’s built into the lid. This is one of the features that makes it a good option for fishermen. It also has UV inhibitors that protect it from the sun.

This cooler has a stain and odor resistant liner and comfort grip handles. It can hold up to 140 cans at once.

Most reviewers were very impressed by this cooler’s ice life. They found that these coolers are able to stay cold for almost an entire week. They also felt the handles make them very easy to carry in wet, marine environments.

Unfortunately, lots of customers had issues with these handles breaking. This is a very common problem with these coolers. The fact that replacement handles aren’t readily available makes this problem even worse.

The IGLOO Marine Ultra Cooler is a good product that’s similar to the Coleman Xtreme in a lot of ways. However, there’s a very good chance you’ll end up with broken handles if you go with them. The Coleman Xtreme is a longer-lasting product in general.

Pros

  • Good ice retention
  • A few unique features
  • Well suited for marine environments

Cons

  • Handles are prone to breaking

Where to buy

REYLEO COOLER

REYLEO Cooler, Rotomolded Cooler 21-Quart, 2:1...
  • 【Christmas Present...
  • 【Built Sturdy & Sealed...
  • 【Uv Protection &...
  • 【4-in-1 Function】 : With...
  • 【Mobile Flexible】: With it...

The REYLEO Cooler is another potential cooler alternative. This cooler has a few interesting features. These include a 16-inch fishing ruler, a bottle opener, 2 cup holders, and a drain plug pressure relief valve.

It can hold 30 cans at one time, and it keeps ice cold for up to 3 days. This cooler also has a strong, rotomolded construction that can withstand up to 700 pounds of pressure.

Furthermore, this cooler has UV protection, so you don’t have to worry about sunlight damage. It also has a non-slip bottom that keeps it stable while you’re using it.

Reviewers generally appreciated this cooler’s vast array of convenient features. They were also impressed by its sturdy construction. This is a strong little cooler that can even handle a bear attack without being destroyed.

The biggest problem with this cooler is its ice retention. Compared to many other coolers on the market, it just doesn’t last very long. You can expect it to stay cold for only two or three days at a time.

This is a good cooler, but the Coleman Xtreme Cooler surpasses it in almost every way. It’s much larger, and it stays cold for longer periods of time. Therefore, we recommend sticking with the Coleman Xtreme Cooler.

Pros

  • Lots of cool features
  • Extremely durable
  • Very light and portable

Cons

  • It’s very small
  • Poor ice retention

Where to buy

ORCA 26 QUART

ORCA ORCT026 26qt Tan Cooler
  • 26 quart cooler
  • Integrated insulation...
  • Includes attached cargo net...
  • 100% USA Made, Lifetime...
  • Lid Gasket to ensure a perfect...

Finally, we have the ORCA 26 Quart. This cooler features a durable, rotomolded construction. It promises to keep ice cold for an astounding 10 days straight.

It also comes with an attached cargo net for added storage and flex-grip handles, which make it easy to carry. Additionally, it has a lid gasket that ensures a tight seal.

Furthermore, this cooler uses an easy-drain spout. As implied by the name, the ORCA 26 can hold up to 26 quarts at one time.

Most reviewers really loved how long this cooler keeps ice cold. While it doesn't quite hit its 10-day goal, it still lasts much longer than the average cooler. It's also very durable and easy to use.

Unfortunately, this cooler's drain doesn't work, as well as one would hope. It's prone to leaking. And to state the obvious, the ORCA 26 is much smaller than a Coleman Xtreme.

In this case, your decision will largely come down to size versus ice retention. The ORCA 26 lasts longer than the Coleman Xtreme, but it can't compete in terms of size. You'll have to decide for yourself which one of these qualities is more important to you.

Pros

  • Terrific ice retention
  • Very durable
  • A few useful features

Cons

  • The drain tends to leak
  • Relatively small size

Where to buy

COLEMAN XTREME COOLER PROS AND CONS

You can probably tell from reading this Coleman Xtreme Cooler review that this cooler has several good qualities. Foremost of these is the price. The Coleman Xtreme is simply more affordable than a lot of what’s out there.

This cooler also retains ice for a decently long time considering the price. Moreover, it’s a big cooler that can hold plenty of drinks. On top of that, it’s portable, easy to use, and has several nice features.

Because of these qualities, some people consider the Coleman Xtreme Cooler to be one of the best coolers for camping.

On the downside, the Coleman Xtreme doesn’t offer much in terms of durability. The handles and the drain, in particular, are noticeable weak spots. And while the ice retention is decent, it doesn’t compare to more expensive coolers.

Pros

  • It’s affordable
  • It’s a big cooler
  • Decent ice retention
  • A few interesting features

Cons

  • Poorly designed handles and drain
  • Low durability in general
  • Ice retention is merely average

IS THIS THE COOLER YOU’VE BEEN LOOKING FOR?

cooler with fish

image by pixabay

Now that you’ve read this Coleman Xtreme Cooler review, there’s only one question remaining. Is this the cooler for you?

At the end of the day, this will largely come down to your budget. If you have some extra cash to spare, you might consider investing in a more expensive cooler. This way, you’ll get a more durable product that will last longer.

But if you’re on a budget, the Coleman Xtreme will definitely get the job done. It’s a great product if you’re looking for a large cooler to take on a weekend trip, and you’re careful with your equipment.

But what do you think? Have you ever tried any of Coleman’s products? Let us know about it in the comments!

Featured image by: Amazon

The Out sider

Get the latest product reviews and advice for hunting, survival, camping and the great outdoors.

See Also


Related Reads

Recent Posts

Pin It on Pinterest